Where you can find us…

Lucy’s Whey offers a large, carefully chosen selection of artisan and farmstead cheeses, with a focus on American-made cheese. Each cheese is unique and presents distinctive flavors that reflect the region and ingenuity of the cheesemaker. In addition to cheese, we carry a variety of complementary foods. Jams, marmalades, mustards, chutneys, pickles, honeys, crackers, and dried fruits have been carefully selected from small producers across the United States and around the world.

  • Carnegie Hill
  • Chelsea Market
  • Amagansett Farmer's Market

The Carnegie Hill location of Lucy’s Whey features a specialty food shop, café, and wine bar. The cheese counter is stocked with the artisan and farmstead cheeses Lucy’s shops are known for, as well as a hand-picked selection of European classics and the highest quality charcuterie, sliced to order. Stop by in the morning for a carefully crafted cappuccino and a handmade pastry, or linger in the afternoon or evening over a glass of wine or craft beer, and enjoy a full menu of cheeses, crostini, salads, and small bites. Our Mac & Cheese is a favorite at both lunch and dinner, and our soup and sandwich combinations are perfect at lunch. This location also offers a selection of prepared foods, farm-fresh dairy products, and every type of cheese accoutrements you could imagine. The team at Lucy’s Whey Carnegie Hill is passionate about helping you craft the perfect cheese plate, pack a picnic lunch, or unwind over exquisite food and drink.

Monday through Thursday: Cafe and Wine Bar 11am-9:30pm | Cheese Shop 9am-8pm

Friday: Cafe and Wine Bar 11am-10pm | Cheese Shop 9am-8pm

Saturday: Cafe and Wine Bar 10am-10pm | Cheese Shop 9am-8pm

Sunday: Cafe and Wine Bar 10am-9:30pm | Cheese Shop 10am-7pm

1417 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10128
(212) 289-8900

This Lucy’s Whey outpost offers a curated selection of American artisanal cheeses, in the convenience of the bustling Chelsea Market. Here, our expert team of cheesemongers will assist you in selecting artisanal cheeses, farmstead preserves, local honey, small batch crackers and sweet treats. This location is also home to our famous grilled cheeses! Each day, we offer a variety of toasty, perfectly melted sandwiches- from the classic white cheddar with fig jam, to the bolder Gruyere with rosemary ham.

Open 7 days a week

Monday through Saturday: 10 am – 8 pm

Sunday: 10 am – 7 pm

425 West 15th St
New York, NY 10011
(212) 463-9500

This Lucy's Whey outpost is part of the revitalized Amagansett Farmer's Market in Amagansett, NY on the eastern coast of Long Island. Here, Lucy sells cheeses and other products primarily from New York State. Stop by to shop some for some of New York's finest cheeses and peruse the rest of the market for great local product from out east.

Friday and Saturday: 10am - 5pm

Through October 2015


367 Main Street

Amagansett, NY 11930